Thanksgiving is about many things—loved ones, turkey, football. But our favorite part of the holiday might just be the excuse to eat as much pie as we can dream of. Luckily, there are plenty of local bakeries and coffee shops serving up delicious Thanksgiving pies in St. Pete.
Whether it’s for friendsgiving, the whole family, or just you and whatever looks good on Netflix, there’s no bad excuse for eating a fresh-baked pie. Here are some of the top spots in St. Pete to find a great pie this Thanksgiving and holiday season.
ADVERTISEMENT
Some of these you’ll need to order well in advance. A handful you can pick up any time you like. Be sure to check with individual businesses for details on ordering and pickup.
Know a great spot we missed? Shoot us an email at info@ilovetheburg.com so we can add it!


Top spots for pie in St. Pete
Bandit
2662 Central Ave
This popular coffee shop and cafe is known for its creative menus that just keep getting better and better. This year, they’re bringing two sweet additions to the Thanksgiving table: a Key Lime Pie and a Sweet Potato Pie, along with a selection of baked goods and pastries to round out your feast. Preorder your treats now!
Cafe Clementine
255 Beach Drive NE
Cafe Clementine makes some of the prettiest treats in town, and pies are no exception. Thanksgiving specials include a Pumpkin Basque Cheesecake and a Rosemary Dutch Apple Pie. Preorders close November 19th.
Cake Affection
4691 100th Way N
All the specialty Thanksgiving pies here are handmade from scratch. Try Mixed Berry Crumble, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan, or Grandma’s Apple Pie.
Craft Kafe
200 Central Ave, 6653 Central Ave
Gluten-free indulgence comes by the pound this Thanksgiving. Local favorite Craft Kafe is dishing up pumpkin pie, pecan pie, and apple crumb pie—all sans gluten. Allow 48 hours for pre-orders.

HaleLife Bakery
11270 4th St. N
These amazing baked goods just happen to be gluten-free, vegan, and allergen-friendly, making them a treat everyone can enjoy. This year’s menu features Pumpkin Pie, Apple Crumble Pie, and Peach Cobbler, alongside savory sides and rolls. Online preorders are available through November 20.
La Segunda Bakery
2424 4th St N
This historic Cuban bakery is bringing all the holiday classics to the table this year. Choose from a selection of traditional pies, including apple, pecan, sweet potato, and pumpkin. Call or stop by the bakery to place your preorder.
Mami Mia Bakery
2070 Bayshore Blvd, Dunedin
This gluten-free hotspot in Dunedin has a wide range of pies this year, including traditional favorites like Apple Pie, Pecan Pie, and Pumpkin Pie. Call to preorder!
Valhalla Bakery
2444 Central Ave
Valhalla has some of the best baked goods in St. Pete all year long. For Thanksgiving, try out any of these options: Pumpkin, Sweet Potato, Mulled Apple Streusel, Chocolate Streusel, or Toasted Coconut.

















